Smokers

There is no perfect smoker, and anyone telling you otherwise is usually selling one. There’s a smoker that fits how much time you actually have on a Saturday, how much yard space you’ve got, and how much you enjoy fussing with a fire versus setting a temperature and walking away.

Pellet smokers like the Traeger I run are the closest thing to a set-it-and-forget-it option — you get consistent heat and real smoke flavor without babysitting a firebox. That said, you’re trading some of the deep, complex smoke an offset produces for that convenience, and pellet purists aren’t wrong to point that out. Offsets and vertical smokers give you more control over the fire and, honestly, more smoke ring for the effort. They also ask more of you: more fuel management, more temperature swings, more mornings that start at 5 a.m.

Electric smokers sit in between — easier than an offset, more hands-on than a pellet grill, and a reasonable answer if you’re smoking somewhere you can’t run wood or charcoal at all.

Figure out which trade-off you’re actually willing to make before you buy. The smoker that matches your patience will get used. The one that doesn’t will turn into a lawn ornament by July.

Scroll to Top